Two major law firms, DLA Piper and Jones Day, are grappling with lawsuits that could reshape how pregnancy and parental leave policies are enforced in the workplace.
DLA Piper is defending itself against claims that it unlawfully terminated an associate after she disclosed her pregnancy and requested maternity leave. The associate alleges she was fired just days after formally applying for leave, despite receiving salary increases and bonuses during her time at the firm. She contends that no performance reviews or warnings were provided prior to her termination.
The firm argues the termination was due to ongoing performance issues. DLA Piper maintains that from the beginning, the associate made critical errors, such as missing deadlines and providing incorrect legal advice that could have exposed clients to risk. The firm insists the decision had no connection to her pregnancy and was purely based on her failure to meet expectations. This case is currently being litigated in the Southern District of New York.
Jones Day faces a different legal challenge related to its parental leave policy.
The lawsuit, brought by two former associates, claims that the firm’s policy discriminates against men. Under the policy, female attorneys receive 18 weeks of paid leave, while male attorneys are entitled to 10 weeks. The plaintiffs argue that this discrepancy reinforces outdated gender stereotypes, where women are seen as primary caregivers.
Jones Day defends its policy, stating that the additional eight weeks for women are necessary to account for postpartum recovery, a medical necessity. The plaintiffs, however, claim that this distinction is discriminatory, as it limits fathers’ ability to take equal time for child-rearing.
The trial is set for 2025 in the United States District Court for the District of Columbia.
Implications for Employment Law
As parental leave and pregnancy-related rights and protections become more common, these lawsuits could set precedent that influence employer policies across industries. Employers may need to reevaluate their approaches to ensure compliance with federal laws like the Family and Medical Leave Act and Title VII of the Civil Rights Act, while also considering employee fairness, workplace optics, and overall company morale.
You can subscribe to our latest alerts and insights here.